Chocolate Peanut Butter Hearts

Last February I found myself suddenly single three days before Valentine's Day, determined not to spend the evening feeling sorry for myself. I raided my pantry and started making these chocolate peanut butter hearts simply because I needed something to do with my hands. The melted chocolate smelled so incredible that my roommate wandered in, and we ended up sitting on the kitchen floor eating the slightly imperfect ones straight from the parchment paper. Now they are my go to reminder that the best celebrations are the ones you create for yourself.

My niece helped me make a batch last year and proceeded to decorate each heart with different sprinkles while demanding we taste test at every stage. The freezer time is crucial but also creates this perfect window to pour a glass of wine and catch up with someone you have been missing. Every time I make them now I think about chocolate fingerprints on her cheeks and how the kitchen somehow looked more beautiful covered in powdered sugar clouds.

Ingredients

• Creamy peanut butter: The brand matters less than you would think but natural peanut butters can separate so stir well before measuring
• Unsalted butter softened: Room temperature butter incorporates into the peanut butter seamlessly creating that smooth melt in your mouth texture
• Powdered sugar: This sweetens and stabilizes the filling so it holds its heart shape beautifully after freezing
• Pure vanilla extract: A half teaspoon might seem small but it rounds out the peanut butter flavor beautifully
• Pinch of salt: Salt is the secret weapon that makes the chocolate taste more intense and the peanut butter feel richer
• Dark chocolate: Good quality chocolate makes all the difference here since the coating is half the eating experience
• Coconut oil: This is optional but creates that gorgeous glossy finish and makes the chocolate coating snappy when you bite into it

Instructions

Make the peanut butter filling:

Beat the peanut butter and softened butter together until completely smooth and no lumps remain then add the powdered sugar vanilla and salt mixing until a soft dough forms that holds together when pressed

Shape the hearts:

Roll the dough between parchment paper to half inch thickness and cut hearts with your cutter transferring them to a parchment lined baking sheet and freezing until firm

Melt the chocolate:

Gently melt the chocolate with coconut oil using a double boiler or microwave in short bursts stirring until completely smooth and glossy

Coat the hearts:

Dip each frozen heart into the melted chocolate using a fork letting excess drip off before returning to the parchment and refrigerating until set

Save to Pinterest

These hearts have become my unexpected connection maker. I left a box on my neighbor's doorstep after she had a terrible week and she texted me two days later saying they saved her evening after a particularly brutal shift at the hospital. Food is just food until you share it and then suddenly it becomes a tiny act of love that travels farther than you expected.

Making Ahead

The peanut butter centers can be frozen for up to a week before dipping which means you can do the messy part days ahead and just coat them when needed.

Storage Secrets

Keep these chilled because the chocolate stays snappy and the filling firms up perfectly. They actually develop deeper flavor after a day or two in the refrigerator.

Creative Variations

Sometimes the classic version is exactly what you need but small twists can make these feel brand new. I have found that subtle changes keep the recipe exciting without complicating the process.

• Swap milk chocolate for dark if you prefer a sweeter coating
• Mix crushed roasted peanuts into the filling for unexpected crunch
• Drizzle white chocolate across the tops for a pretty finished look

Save to Pinterest

There is something deeply satisfying about making your own candy especially when it looks this impressive and tastes this good. These hearts always seem to find their way to the people who need them most.

Your Recipe Questions

→ How do I make the peanut butter filling smooth?

Beat the peanut butter and softened butter together until creamy before adding powdered sugar and vanilla to ensure a smooth texture.

→ What chocolate works best for coating?

Good-quality dark or semisweet chocolate provides a rich, smooth coating. Adding coconut oil helps achieve a glossy finish.

→ Can I add crunch to the filling?

Yes, finely chopped roasted peanuts can be mixed into the filling for added texture and crunch.

→ How long should the hearts chill before dipping?

Freeze the shaped hearts for about 25–30 minutes to firm them up before dipping into melted chocolate.

→ What storage method is best for these treats?

Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to one week to maintain freshness and texture.

→ Can this be made vegan?

Swap butter for dairy-free butter and use vegan dark chocolate to create a plant-based version.